1) Captain's Cove just west of 94 and south of 20 (Sturtevant). Good panko-crusted cod. Includes all-you-can-eat salad bar.

2) Hiawatha Bar at Wisconsin and Durand (Sturtevant). Good beer-battered cod.

3) Fritz's on Douglas just north of 3 mile (Racine). Good fish and "cheesy" potato casserole.

Another fav is Erv's Mug at the nw corner of Howell and Ryan (Oak Creek). I know the location precludes it from being included in the "local" contest of this blog, but it is good nonetheless and worth mentioning.

DeRango's on 6 Mile.

Village Deli inside BP is Sturtevant, so good!

Just had the pollack at Shuffle Bear North. I thought it was VERY good.
Friend had the baked cod and also indicated it was very good.

My wife and I are addicted to the cod fish fry at Culvers. I have no idea how they make it so consistently good each and every time. We usually buy the 3 piece and split it between each of us because it's all so filling and yummy. Have never had a bad fish dinner there so far, no matter which location we go to. That's my story and I'm sticking to it.

We really like Gus's on Goold & Douglas.
I don't think their Fish Fry is homemade...possibly a pre-battered Sysco cod, but it's crispy and hot with 3 larges pieces and they have homemade fries and good coleslaw. Plus, it's only $4.50.

Danny's Meat market has great fish fry, too and now that he has bought Kayne's, you can sit down and eat it instead of taking it to go.

@Staci -- Danny rocks in my book too. But I haven't tried the fish fry there.

SBN SHUFFLE BEAR NORTH! they have the best fish fry. The fish is all hand breaded and seasoned and very fresh.

Fritz's on Douglas (and its in Caledonia, not Racine

2 readers sent email with votes for the Yardarm ...

Received this vote via email:
This is a great topic since we usually go "out of town" for fish fries
since we try to avoid fried foods. We like the baked fish at Polenez
(St. Francis), where the fish comes with soup, salad, potato pancakes,
washed down with any number of great Polish beers. Karl Ratzsch
Restaurant in downtown Milwaukee etudes German charm and serves a nice
fish fry, again with potato pancakes as an option. But the real
question now for us is where does the fish come from? We try to avoid
farmed fish as well as those from Asian Pacific waters. Despite
Americans love affair with tilapia we find it bland. How can we
determine where to dine based on these criteria? As a postscript we
usually run to Yardarm for a quick fish "fry".

the question is who has the best fish fry in MT PLEASANT, CALEDONIA OR STURTEVANT, NOT RACINE, OAK CREEK OR ANY PLACE ELSE

Anyone ever try Roma Lodge?? Been thinking about trying them...I think they have take out during lent.

We had takeout from Roma Lodge last Friday and were very disappointed. Portion size on all three dinners was small, especially om the baked dinner. We ordered seasoned fries with all the dinners. One dinner had only a few fries and a baked potato. There were no rolls or bread with any of the dinners,, Defnitely NOT worth the price.

It's Friday, and I want to thank everyone for submitting their recommendations. Tonight, our family is going out for a fish fry and we're going to try all of these places over the coming weeks.

Shuffle Bear North

John E T
Shuffle Bear North, Beats them all. More bang for your buck.
Great Alaskin Pollack,Cod, Perch, Wallie, always fresh, never over cooked.
prefect breading.Very tasty fries, try the cheesey potatoe balls, bet you can't eat just one! Great homemade coleslaw.
I,ve tried them all. If you leave hungry, It's your fault.
Lots of freindly people, a great atmosphere, you won't be disappointed.

Hi everyone! We had 125 votes in our Best Fish Fry poll. Watch for the winner at noon, and thanks for participating!